Create / Edit

Yii 1.1 General Discussion
1

Do you think it is better to combine the create / edit record methods in the controller into 1 method?

Or have them as two seperate methods?

2

IMHO is better to have them separated. I think is less confusing and more scalable in big projects. But that is just my opinion.

3

Thanks.

4

Ok what about in the view layer, is it best to have them seperate or all as one view.

i.e. using the if($model->isNewRecord) etc.

5

The view layer is a different story all together. I try to create views that i can share among controller’s actions.

6

I have done a similar thing.

I did have my create / edit in the controller, now they two seperate methods. in the view I have joined them up.